"The Straight Mind" by M. Wittig
Summary by Michelle Attebury and Kate Wunsch
- The straight mind is the mind that has throughly internalized the ideas
produced by the thought of dominance ("The Category of Sex") and
applies to every field. As Wittig wrote, "I can only underlinmce the
oppressice character that the straight mind is clothed in its tendancy to
immediately universalize ots production of concepts into general laws which
claim to hold true for all societies all epochs, all indiviuals. Thus one
speaks of the exchange of women, the difference between the sexes, the symbolic
order, the Unconcious, Desire, Jouissance, Culture, History, giving absolute
meaning to these concepts when they are only categories founded upon
heterosexuality, or thought which produces the difference between the sexes as
political ans philosophicla dogma." (146).
- The obligatory social relationship between men and women is the
heterosexual relationship. This relationship is necessary for society to run as
all of society's institutions are based on it-family, work, etc. That is why
dominate ideologies ordain heterosexuality as 'natural' and acknowledge
homosexuality as 'other', as it is seen as a threat to the order. This
naturlaization of heterosexuality is called compulsory heterosexuality.
- For example in psychoanalysis, all of the symbols in the Unconcious (like
the Oedipus complex, castration, murder-or-death-of-the-father, the exchange of
men, etc.) assume every person is heterosexual, misogynistic, and that they were
born with this Unconcious. The Unconcious is supposedly 'universal', across all
cultures. In actuality, these theories were produced by straight minds to
silence homosexuality and to make heterosexuality the law. As Wittig says, "No
wonder then that there is only one
Unconcious, and that it is heterosexual. It is an Unconcious which looks
too conciously after the interests of the masters." (148).
Opinions
-I think Wittig has some very good and valid points, but at times I think
she gets a bit carried with herself. In her other piece that we read she talks
about the "...class struggle between men and women, which should be
undertaken by all women..." and goes on to say "Women do not know that
they are totally dominated by ne, and when they acknowledge that fact, they can
'hardly believe it'," ("The Category of Sex" pg 25). I think
comments like these are overly dramatic and don't pertain to all, or any?,
women. However, I do like the work she does showing the built in assumptions in
psychoanalysis.